STUD or DUD? Has Porsche Revealed The EV We've Been Waiting For OR Is It Too Little, Too Late?

STUD or DUD? Has Porsche Revealed The EV We've Been Waiting For OR Is It Too Little, Too Late?
Today marked a very special day in Porsche history. And, perhaps, automotive history.

That's because it has launched its first ever fully electric vehicle. Many industry pundits have been waiting for this day as the Taycan has long been considered the top challenger set to dethrone Tesla.

Frankfurt Motor Show Photo Gallery

There's just a couple problems with this thesis now that we've received more details. This is how it breaks down on paper:

The Taycan Turbo starts at a base price of about $151,000* USD and only achieves about 256 miles on a full charge.

The Taycan Turbo S starts at a base price of about $185,000* USD and only achieves about 280 miles on a full charge.

The Tesla Model S Performance costs about $115,000* USD fully tricked out and achieves about 345 miles on a full charge. And if you order one today Tesla estimates you'll have your fresh from the factory car in about three weeks.

There's a lot to consider here, Spies, but ultimately one has to ask: Is the Porsche really worth $70,000 MORE than the Tesla? Is the all-new Porsche Taycan a STUD or DUD?



Frankfurt Motor Show Photo Gallery




Porsche's press release follows:

World premiere of the Porsche Taycan: Sports car, sustainably redesigned

Toronto/Berlin/Fuzhou. Porsche presented its first fully-electric sports car to the public today with a spectacular world premiere held simultaneously on three continents. "The Taycan links our heritage to the future. It carries forward the success story of our brand – a brand that has fascinated and thrilled people the world over for more than 70 years," said Oliver Blume, Chairman of the Executive Board of Porsche AG, who opened the world premiere in Berlin: "This day marks the start of a new era."

The four-door sports saloon is a unique package, offering typical Porsche performance and connectivity with everyday usability. At the same time, highly advanced production methods and the features of the Taycan are setting new standards in the fields of sustainability and digitalisation. “We promised a true Porsche for the age of electromobility – a fascinating sports car that not only excites in terms of its technology and driving dynamics, but also sparks a passion in people all over the world, just like its legendary predecessors have done. Now we are delivering on this promise,” emphasises Michael Steiner, Member of the Executive Board of Porsche AG – Research and Development.

The first models in the new series are the Taycan Turbo S and Taycan Turbo. They are at the cutting edge of Porsche E-Performance and are among the most powerful production models that the sports car manufacturer currently has in its product range. Less powerful variants of these all-wheel drive vehicles will follow this year. The first derivative to be added will be the Taycan Cross Turismo at the end of next year. By 2022, Porsche will have invested more than six billion euros in electromobility.

Performance meets efficiency
The flagship Turbo S version of the Taycan can generate up to 560 kW (761 PS) overboost power in combination with Launch Control, and the Taycan Turbo up to 500 kW (680 PS). The Taycan Turbo S accelerates from zero to 100 km/h in 2.8 seconds, while the Taycan Turbo completes this sprint in 3.2 seconds. The Turbo S has a range of up to 412 kilometres, and the Turbo a range of up to 450 kilometres (according to WLTP in each case). The top speed of both all-wheel-drive models is 260 km/h.

The Taycan is the first production vehicle with a system voltage of 800 volts instead of the usual 400 volts for electric cars. This is a particular advantage for Taycan drivers on the road: in just over five minutes, the battery can be recharged using direct cur-rent (DC) from the high-power charging network for a range of up to 100 kilometres (according to WLTP). The charging time for five to 80 percent SoC (state of charge) is 22.5 minutes for charging under ideal conditions, and the maximum charging power (peak) is 270 kW. The overall capacity of the Performance Battery Plus is 93.4 kWh. Taycan drivers can comfortably charge their cars with up to eleven kW of alternating current (AC) at home. 

The Porsche Taycan Turbo S and Porsche Taycan Turbo are now available to order and cost 185,456 euros and 152,136 euros respectively in Germany, including country-specific equipment and VAT.

Pure exterior design with Porsche DNA
With its clean, puristic design, the Taycan signals the beginning of a new era. At the same time, it retains the unmistakable Porsche design DNA. From the front it looks particularly wide and flat with highly contoured wings. The silhouette is shaped by the sporty roofline sloping downward to the rear. The highly sculpted side sections are also characteristic. The sleek cabin, the drawn-in rear C-pillar and the pronounced shoulders of the wings result in a sharply emphasised rear, typical of the brand. There are also innovative elements such as the glass-effect Porsche logo, which has been integrated into the light bar at the rear. With a Cd value from 0.22, the aerodynamically optimised basic shape makes a significant contribution to low energy consumption and thus long range.

Unique interior design with a wide display screen band
The cockpit signals the start of a new era with its clear structure and a completely new architecture. The freestanding, curved instrument cluster forms the highest point on the dashboard. This places a clear focus on the driver axis. A central, 10.9-inch infotainment display and an optional passenger display are combined to form an integrated glass band in a black-panel look. All user interfaces have been completely newly designed for the Taycan. The number of classic hardware controls such as switches and buttons has been greatly reduced. Instead, control is intelligent and intuitive – using touch operation or the voice control function, which responds to the command “Hey Porsche”.

With the Taycan, Porsche offers an entirely leather-free interior for the first time. Interiors made from innovative recycled materials underscore the sustainable concept of the electric sports car. “Foot garages” – recesses in the battery in the rear footwell – ensure sitting comfort in the rear and allow the low vehicle height typical of sports cars. Two luggage compartments are available: the front compartment has a capacity of 81 litres and the rear 366 litres.

Innovative drive motors and a two-speed transmission
The Taycan Turbo S and Taycan Turbo have two exceptionally efficient electric ma-chines, one on the front axle and one on the rear axle, thus making the cars all-wheel drive. Both the range and the continuous power of the drive benefit from the high efficiency of the permanently excited synchronous machines. The electric machine, transmission and pulse-controlled inverter are each combined into a compact drive module. The modules have the highest power density (kW per litre of package space) of all electric powertrains on the market today. A special feature of the electric motors is the "hairpin" winding of the stator coils. This technology makes it possible to incorporate more copper in the stator, increasing power output and torque while maintaining the same component volume. The two-speed transmission installed on the rear axle is an innovation developed by Porsche. First gear gives the Taycan even more acceleration from a standing start, while second gear with a long gear ratio ensures high efficiency and equally high power reserves. This also applies at very high speeds.

Centrally networked chassis systems
Porsche uses a centrally networked control system for the Taycan chassis. The inte-grated Porsche 4D Chassis Control analyses and synchronises all chassis systems in real time. The innovative chassis systems include adaptive air suspension with three-chamber technology including PASM (Porsche Active Suspension Management) electronic damper control, as well as the Porsche Dynamic Chassis Control Sport (PDCC Sport) electromechanical roll stabilisation system including Porsche Torque Vectoring Plus (PTV Plus). The all-wheel drive control with two electric motors and the recuperation system are unique. At up to 265 kW, the potential recuperation power is significantly higher than that of competitors. Driving tests have shown that approximately 90 percent of everyday braking is performed by the electric machines alone – without the hydraulic wheel brakes being activated.

The profile of the different driving modes basically follows the same philosophy as in other Porsche model series. This is supplemented by special settings which enable optimum use of the purely electric drive. Four driving modes are available: “Range”, “Normal”, “Sport” and “Sport Plus”. In addition, individual systems can be configured as required in the “Individual” mode. 

A world premiere on three continents at the same time
The Porsche Taycan’s world premiere took place simultaneously in North America, China and Europe. The most important sales markets of the new electric sports car are on these three continents. The event locations are also a synonym for three ways of sustainable energy management: Niagara Falls at the border between the US state of New York and the Canadian province of Ontario representing hydro-power, a solar farm in Neuhardenberg near Berlin representing solar power and a wind farm on Pingtan Island, around 150 kilometres from the Chinese city of Fuzhou in the province of Fujian representing wind power. We perceive these natural forces with all our senses in exactly the same way as we experience the impressive power delivery of the first all-electric sports car from Porsche. This one-time triple event was broadcast worldwide via live stream on 
NewsTV.porsche.com.


Frankfurt Motor Show Photo Gallery
































































runninglogan1runninglogan1 - 9/5/2019 12:15:50 AM
-3 Boost
I love the Taycan but it's WAY too expensive. I specced out a Turbo on the configurator and it came to $203k. My Turbo S came to $232k! Lol.

They don't even come with lane departure warning as standard so you know you're going to be checking some option boxes. And they're EXPENSIVE. Even a Civic has that as standard equipment.

We're talking Aston Martin and Bentley territory here. I don't see how they could possibly move 30,000 per year at these prices.

The base models better come out ASAP.

Definitely not a Model S competitor as I had hoped. Completely different price point.


runninglogan1runninglogan1 - 9/5/2019 12:18:45 AM
-1 Boost
BTW, Turbo S will have a range closer to 220 miles, not 280 as stated in the article. Regular Turbo will actually have a bit more range but still way short of Model S.


atc98092atc98092 - 9/5/2019 7:58:36 AM
+10 Boost
It's priced the same as the 911 with the same performance and options. So it's priced as a Porsche, not anything else. So, it's priced for the market. Way out of my price range, sure. But so is any other Porsche.


CANADIANCOMMENTSCANADIANCOMMENTS - 9/5/2019 10:00:40 PM
-7 Boost
Swell. So about $300k - $350k CAD. Nobody will buy this at that price over a Tesla. They will look, maybe take a test drive. But spec vs price of what is offered is out of whack.


runninglogan1runninglogan1 - 9/5/2019 2:14:16 AM
-2 Boost
Not really pre-sold. 30,000 people placed refundable deposits to be first in line to get one. Wonder how many will back out upon realizing it will cost them at least $150k - probably much more - for their Taycan.


MDarringerMDarringer - 9/5/2019 8:17:11 AM
-1 Boost
Actually, it's unlikely 30K people put money down. "Orders" is the term used for stock they plan to push out to dealers. It kind of like how Tesla uses "sales" and the amount they say they might build.


wilfredwilfred - 9/5/2019 1:48:16 AM
+7 Boost
I can certainly understand why the Taycan is often compared to the Tesla. But let’s be real, the Taycan is made by Porsche, a real car manufacturer and consumers know if anything happens, the manufacturer will be around to go after whether it’s for service issues, parts availability, or even litigation if necessary.

Tesla on the other end is somewhere between a Tucker and a DeLoren. While I wish them the best, the reality is the best that can happen is it’ll be bought out by a company that can afford Elon’s hope & dream...

Meanwhile, Porsche will have no problem finding buyers for the Taycan in the almost $200k market. Given it’s traditional $10-20k options... And in another year or so, there should be a Taycan and/or Taycan S, in the lower $100k market. And then the Macan EV, I guess that will be the sub $100k market.






TruthyTruthy - 9/5/2019 11:36:16 AM
+2 Boost
Good analysis.


cidflekkencidflekken - 9/5/2019 3:35:45 AM
-5 Boost
Disappointed. Already has a dated feel to the exterior. Digital display overload on the inside. That range is not competitive and don’t fool yourself by thinking rich EV buyers don’t care about range. Rich folks don’t want to wait to recharge mid-trip.


PUGPROUDPUGPROUD - 9/5/2019 5:46:05 AM
+7 Boost
The price of exclusivity which sells in small numbers at high margins. Porsche knows what it is doing and knows their customers.


SanJoseDriverSanJoseDriver - 9/5/2019 6:36:58 AM
-5 Boost
The final design and specs ended up being much nicer than what I expected. $200k+ with options though?? You can get a brand new Model S Performance for $99k and it already includes everything you need except for Autopilot, no upgrades necessary.

What blows me away is Porsche had over 3 years and all this amazing engineering talent at their disposal to come up with a P100D competitor, and they were not able to release a car--even at an astronomical price point--with a faster 0-60 than Tesla. It's also a smaller and lighter car with a better drag coefficient and more horsepower than the Model S, this makes no mathematical sense.


TomMTomM - 9/5/2019 8:24:29 AM
+8 Boost
Comparing the model S to this car is like comparing a Yugo to a Phantom.
Lots of cars are made from Entry level and mid level manufacturers that are larger and faster than some High End Premium cars - but if you want a Porsche - you want a Porsche - the model S - a mid level entry - won't do. And a Tesla is a wannabe - not the real thing.


Up till now we have not had a real Premium Entry into the EV fray from a real Premium name. THey will likely sell lots of them. But - wait another 2 years - when virtually EVERYONE will have EVs available. WE still do not have any idea of the real size of the market.


TruthyTruthy - 9/5/2019 11:41:22 AM
+7 Boost
You can get a Chrysler 300 for a lot less than a MB S-Class too. Porsche was not trying to compete with the Mosel S.
0 - 60 is your only metric?!? What about being able to launch repeatedly without overheating the battery? What about world class brakes, interior, handling?
Oh, and 0 to 80 percent charge in 23 minutes.


TruthyTruthy - 9/5/2019 6:14:51 PM
+6 Boost
Unless there is a fire truck on the track then the Tesla is toast.


Agent00RAgent00R - 9/5/2019 8:59:13 AM
-3 Boost
Way to go hyperbolic.

I'll keep you around just for laughs...


TomMTomM - 9/5/2019 8:28:26 AM
+9 Boost
Porsche is clearly doing what that other brand did - it is purposely producing only the high end versions first. However - you can bet that eventually they will also produce Under $100,000 list versions as well. But as long as they have 30,000 pre-orders - they are not looking for customers.


mre30mre30 - 9/5/2019 9:51:09 AM
+6 Boost
Thanks for all the comments but they are being made thru an "American Lens".

Taycan will sell what it sells in America, but China and Europe where governments are mandating EV's will be where the volume is.

The Model S, in contrast, had only modest sales penetration in global markets due to Tesla's limited working capital and slow global roll-out and now it is obsolete as a luxury vehicle. The Model 3 did not replace it as a luxury vehicle.

The Taycan is going to the the "IT" vehicle worldwide, amongst monied buyers, as EV mandates roll on in China and Europe.


pdperry23pdperry23 - 9/5/2019 11:55:09 AM
-5 Boost
Good effort but not a stud. Specs and price don't match. What's funny is this brand new offering is being compared to an 8 year old car from a startup! And there's a compelling argument that the Tesla is still the smarter choice if you're ready to go EV. Love Porsche, but I'm sure Tesla is saying "stay tuned for our next Model S."


supermotosupermoto - 9/5/2019 12:40:17 PM
+9 Boost
"I'm sure Tesla is saying "stay tuned for our next Model S.""

But Tesla has stated that there is not even a refresh coming for the S, let alone a new version. Tesla simply does not have the cash to invest in new or refreshed models.

Anyway, the buyers for the first batch of Taycans is not sensitive to cost at all. I'm sure the cheaper models will be released as soon as sales start to decline.


TruthyTruthy - 9/5/2019 6:22:00 PM
+8 Boost
What specs are you referring to? The Porsche will drive like a Porsche. It will have the build quality and materials of a Porsche and it will hold up in aggressive driving, charge faster. You see, Porsche is not trying to produce a Model S, they are building a car to Porsche expectations.


skytopskytop - 9/5/2019 1:42:30 PM
0 Boost
The Taycan is worth $70K but not 70K above the price of the Tesla.


pdperry23pdperry23 - 9/5/2019 7:17:34 PM
-4 Boost
What specs? The big ones. Range, speed, technology(no autopilot equivalent). With EVs, range is king, just like horsepower is for dinosaur cars. Again, most of the specs don't match a Model S that's been around for 8 years. Wealthy enthusiasts are not suckers. For $200k, the upcoming Tesla Roadster dominates the Porsche.


mini22mini22 - 9/5/2019 8:25:40 PM
+8 Boost
The reason the Taycan is worth more than a Tesla. Better built, better reliability, more user friendly controls, faster charging, similar performance, way better looking. The other thing is Porsche has probably learned from Tesla's teething problems. There will be less likelihood of a fire. The top 2 models are expensive but they(Porsche) will have base models perhaps with more range. So if I were in the market for a luxury sedan EV and I had a choice between the Tesla model S or X and a base Taycan for similar money. I would still probably go for the Porsche knowing it had less straight line performance. In every other way I would still have more confidence in owning a Porsche over a Tesla.


pdperry23pdperry23 - 9/6/2019 5:51:50 PM
0 Boost
Nice try mini-me. Your price expectation is way off. The Taycan is way more expensive. And when Porsche does come out with less expensive models, it will not have more range and it will not be faster. The spec comparison will be more drastic. You would have a good argument with your last comment if pricing was similar between the two brands, but it's not.


vdivvdiv - 9/5/2019 10:14:41 PM
+2 Boost
Well, if we compare the price to that of a 918 this is a bargain :)

It is late, but not too late, and it is just the beginning for Porsche, now that they are finally serious about ditching the fossils. Once people drive the Taycan they won't go back.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC