Fifth Gear: Audi S5 vs BMW 335i shootout

omarrana submitted on 09/04/2007 Official AutoSpies Timestamp: 3:56 PM
from: www.egmcartech.com

[98] user comments | category: Videos

Tags: BMW, Audi, Fifth, Gear

Tag Links:

BMW

Audi

Fifth

Gear

Fifth Gear: Audi S5 vs BMW 335i shootout

Watch as Fifth Gear’s Vicki Butler-Henderson tests both the Audi S5 and the BMW 335i. The BMW 335i is powered by a 3.0 liter, inline-6, twin-turbo engine that produces 300 horsepower. The Audi S5, on the other hand, is powered by a 4.2 liter V8 engine that produces 354 horsepower.

Click through for the video... Read Article

Comments:

Images hosted in your AgentSpace can now be posted in the comments section using the following syntax (case matters):
[img]IMAGE URL[/img]
Example: [img]http://agent004.myautospies.com/users/150/Sample-Gallery/sample1.JPG[/img]

BenzW124 - 9/4/2007 4:35:43 PM

Show Comment -17 Boost

S4cabriofoxone - 9/4/2007 4:48:49 PMView My AgentSpace

+6 Boost

Wow! Great video. I expected the 335i to win at the track, but it definitely highlighted both coupes' strong points.

reply to this comment

crackityjones - 9/4/2007 11:15:50 PM

+3 Boost

Surprising. The video was fun to watch and well edited. She was haulin'.

adamsaf723 - 9/5/2007 3:14:38 AM

+4 Boost

I wonder if the AWD traction control had anything to do with why the Audi couldn't fully use it's potential. It was more likely the fact that it is substantially heavier.

1995e34 - 9/5/2007 3:38:26 PM

0 Boost

substantially heavier...slowing it down...if only it had rwd...

Larry - 9/4/2007 4:52:49 PM

+5 Boost

both cars same speed not much difference a tenth of a second, there is also not much difference in performance between the V-8 360 hp BMW 550i and the inline 6 BMW 535i.

reply to this comment

Lexus - 9/4/2007 4:58:50 PM

+7 Boost

Wow! to be honest I thought the new Audi S5 would win because it had a V8 and 54hp more than the BMW 335i. Nevertheless, great performance by both cars.

reply to this comment

Audi4Life - 9/4/2007 4:59:21 PM

+7 Boost

the bmw was lighter and audi's quattro makes the car heavier but more stable on the road however it was a very close run. both good cars

reply to this comment

GermanNut - 9/4/2007 5:04:01 PM

-6 Boost

BenzW124 is lying like he always does. BMW wins on styling is your opinion. Yes, it wins on steering. Value it also wins on. Audi wins in reliability, Audi wins in interior, Audi wins in prestige.

BMW please stop having your M3 embarassed by VW/Audi.

reply to this comment

MrGunFun - 9/4/2007 5:21:12 PMView My AgentSpace

+5 Boost

are you kidding me? Audi does not win in prestige on any day.

Pass me what you're smoking.

crackityjones - 9/4/2007 11:16:34 PM

+4 Boost

Or reliability. A tie, at best!

S4cabriofoxone - 9/4/2007 11:55:29 PMView My AgentSpace

-4 Boost

Audi also wins on power, luxury, style, exclusivity. These two are very different but I'd take either, at any price under $100K to be honest. They're both tremendous values.

Kinger - 9/5/2007 4:45:33 AM

+2 Boost

Audi has a bit to go before they're viewed in the same light as BMW in terms of driving dynamics. Style is subjective.

In terms of reliability BMW has been doing well of late, Audi is still down the table: http://www.autoblog.com/photos/j-d-power-2007-vehicle-dependability-study/346679/full/

M53R - 9/6/2007 6:23:39 AMView My AgentSpace

+1 Boost

S4

Thats abit too far.
Audi may win in a straightline but the power in the 335i is nothin short of amazing, plus the S5 is marketed above the 335i and still the BMW handles better. You can have the luxury, but imo the interior in the BMW looks more modern, but Audi wins on quality of the materials. Style... Just because the S5 looks understated doesnt really make it look better. But its your opinion after all. I personally prefer the sharp lines on the 335i, all thanks to Bangle! Exclusivity, well the Audi costs more, so what do you expect? They are not even direct competitors!

Heyhuub - 9/4/2007 5:05:16 PM

+3 Boost

I'm guessing the S5 is allot more softly sprung then the old S4.

When Sport Auto magazine tested the S5 on Hockenheim it was 0.5 seonds slower then the old S4.

reply to this comment

Larry - 9/4/2007 5:12:35 PM

+5 Boost

audi wins in prestige, few people would agree with that, in order to have prestige a company shoulds have a tradition of making fine cars, in the 1970's, 1980's, and 1990's BMW was making M cars when Audi was lucky to market various rebadged Jettas and passats called the Audi 80,90,100, 5000, first A4, A6, TT.

reply to this comment

S4cabriofoxone - 9/4/2007 11:56:48 PMView My AgentSpace

-1 Boost

That was the dark ages of Audi. Before then they were fabulous vehicles, as they are today. Remember Horch? That company was up there with Maybach in terms of luxury and exclusivity in its day, and was actually the first German manufacturer to have a V-8.

Heyhuub - 9/5/2007 3:00:39 AM

+2 Boost

Audi unnofficiale started their s line with the 1968 Audi 100 S Coupe. Their first official S car was the Audi S1 quattro.

Heyhuub - 9/5/2007 3:00:56 AM

+2 Boost

In 1984

gsh23 - 9/4/2007 5:12:58 PM

+5 Boost

ah man, new season of fifth gear is running now? gotta go get it...

reply to this comment

MrGunFun - 9/4/2007 5:22:12 PMView My AgentSpace

+3 Boost

Imagine BMW 335i with performance package!

reply to this comment

jmrA480 - 9/4/2007 5:34:47 PM

+1 Boost

Both cars are awesome, but for me it would be the S5. Just like the looks better and need the quattro living in the northeast.(US)

reply to this comment

JRobUSC - 9/4/2007 6:24:47 PM

+3 Boost

335xi Coupe, arriving at a dealer near you in a month...

cs4444 - 9/4/2007 7:05:10 PMView My AgentSpace

+4 Boost

yeah you need the quattro b/c it snows 5 days out of the year.

ThierryHenry14 - 9/4/2007 7:09:08 PM

-3 Boost

Quattro is not only for the snow, incase you haven't heard. Quattro helps handling...

Star - 9/4/2007 7:46:09 PM

+6 Boost

"Quattro is not only for the snow, incase you haven't heard. Quattro helps handling... "

One would think that this video made clear that Quattro is useless on dry pavement.

jmrA480 - 9/4/2007 8:54:32 PM

+1 Boost

CS- also cause i go sking almost every weekend of the winter.

moto - 9/4/2007 9:43:09 PM

+1 Boost

CS, Star -

If you don't live in the Northeast, then you probably don't understand. The winters here -- even without snow -- are harsh on the roads. We simply don't have the perfect asphalt that people from warm climates enjoy. Yes, quattro is very much appreciated year-round up here. Necessary? no, probably not... but you sure don't see many BMW's around here 9 months out of the year either.

cs4444 - 9/4/2007 9:51:36 PMView My AgentSpace

+4 Boost

haha your funny. i live in Vermont, and i manage to get around just fine with rwd.

S4cabriofoxone - 9/4/2007 11:58:44 PMView My AgentSpace

-2 Boost

The S5 is also more luxurious and sexier. I don't know... it just does it for me. The 335i offers 90% of the S5's core virtues for 85% of the price, but both are very good values.

IamEvilHomer - 9/5/2007 2:52:28 AM

+2 Boost

funny there are 0 rwd cars in Park City

you see SUV's, Trucks, Audi, Subaru, A few MB and BMW Xdrives and some FWD but not to many RWD

IamEvilHomer - 9/5/2007 2:54:33 AM

+2 Boost

jrob if you are getting a 335 that is one thing but a 335xi? come on get an Audi

JRobUSC - 9/5/2007 2:39:30 PM

+1 Boost

Homer, I'm not getting either, I was just pointing out to the guy who says his only choice is the Audi because he needs all-wheel drive that the all-wheel drive 335xi coupe will start arriving next month. He does in fact have a choice.

1995e34 - 9/5/2007 3:47:58 PM

+1 Boost

moto,

where in the northeast do you not see many rwd cars? i know audi and subaru have their strongest following here, but i think the only time i see audis outnumbering bmw or benz is in the parking lots of ski resorts. bmw makes very few 9-month vehicles.

jmrA480 - 9/7/2007 1:00:37 AM

+1 Boost

jrob- I didnt say its my only choice, I said between these 2, one has AWD and the other doesnt.

I could get an SUV if I wanted, but i was picking between these 2.

C4- yea you might get around, but I dont like driving 10MPH around holding up traffic, just so i can drive a BMW. Also Quattro is far superior to X Crap!

SevorbeupstryIsBack - 9/4/2007 5:43:10 PM

+3 Boost

Good to see 5th Gear is back.

But for comparison sake I would like to have seen that 335i WITH M-sport package. It makes a HUGE different really.

reply to this comment

david989 - 9/4/2007 5:54:08 PM

-12 Boost

Why wasn't the Toyota Solara included in this test? It would have gotten my vote.

reply to this comment

enthusiastx11 - 9/4/2007 8:50:42 PM

+4 Boost

this one was actually funny 989.

Htay7500 - 9/5/2007 4:41:02 PM

0 Boost

cause the solara is FWD?

ThierryHenry14 - 9/6/2007 9:56:43 PM

+1 Boost

hey, this is for real david... how old are you? I'm 23, you seem like you are 16, getting your first car soon...

GermanNut - 9/4/2007 6:14:08 PM

-5 Boost

Audi has amazing prestige. It is older than BMW and has been producing cars for a longer period of time. Furthermore, Audi was near extinction and now look at it about to surpass Mercedes in global sales this year or next.

reply to this comment

cs4444 - 9/4/2007 7:00:49 PMView My AgentSpace

+5 Boost

Ford is older than BMW germannut, does that mean its more prestigious?

IamEvilHomer - 9/5/2007 2:53:28 AM

0 Boost

BMW is like the Lakeers SOOOO 1990's

IamEvilHomer - 9/5/2007 2:53:47 AM

+1 Boost

lakeers=lakers

Kinger - 9/5/2007 4:50:53 AM

+2 Boost

Audi doesn't have more prestige than BMW, not over here in Europe, and certainly not in the US. The BMW badge has more cache than the 4 rings, and thats been earned through years of making excelent products, cars like the 507, 635csi, and pretty much every M car ever built.

mini22 - 9/4/2007 6:14:46 PM

0 Boost

david989-Do I detect a bit of sarcasm in your remark?

reply to this comment

audirevolution - 9/4/2007 6:38:53 PM

+6 Boost

I sure do hope he is being sarcastic. The Solora is an ugly, boring POS.

1evlaudi - 9/4/2007 7:22:08 PMView My AgentSpace

+2 Boost

unfortunately he is not.
his continuous comments about Lexuses and toyotas have long proven that he is:
a- completely ignorant
b- a 10 years old kid
c- a trouble maker that likes to start flame wars and he should be banned...

S4cabriofoxone - 9/5/2007 12:00:02 AMView My AgentSpace

-3 Boost

1evlaudi, he has you. Those are not his true beliefs- if you think those things about him, then sorry, he's far more clever than you are.

Kinger - 9/5/2007 4:52:28 AM

0 Boost

He's a German car fan posing as a Lexus fan. Honestly, david989 hates Lexus.

1995e34 - 9/5/2007 4:04:24 PM

+1 Boost

so is will

SevorbeupstryIsBack - 9/4/2007 6:17:38 PM

+5 Boost

The S5 is a great car but it's not a sportscar, it's more of a GT. The MLB chassis is still not fully exploited. The S5 still has a bit of that nose heavy Audi feel, but according to Audi marketing it's what people like. The real grunt should come with the RS5. Just compare the S4 with the RS4, yes the difference will be that big!

reply to this comment

S4cabriofoxone - 9/5/2007 12:01:22 AMView My AgentSpace

-2 Boost

Yes, I read that the engineers were slightly disgruntled to have to make the S5 slightly less exciting than it could have been. Of course, nobody normal would notice the handling difference, but with that extra effort it could have been more clearly cut that the S5 is just better than the 335i. I can't wait for the RS5 to see what they can do with this chassis...

bmwdrvr - 9/4/2007 6:55:52 PM

0 Boost

why do people still keep comparing these 2, lol. i can imagine when the new a4 is released and the tests of the 335i sedan and top a4 begin, the 335i is going to blow it off the road. if its running with the s5 with a 354hp v8

reply to this comment

AdmiralT20 - 9/4/2007 11:12:14 PM

+1 Boost

Because they are close in both performance and size.

pchera01 - 9/4/2007 6:56:57 PM

+4 Boost

WOW, nice video

reply to this comment

Star - 9/4/2007 7:48:22 PM

+3 Boost

Both are great cars but price makes the BMW the better choice.

reply to this comment

S4cabriofoxone - 9/5/2007 12:03:23 AMView My AgentSpace

-1 Boost

I don't know... you get a lot for the price of the S5: more standard luxuries, sexier style, exclusivity, the irresistible torque and sound of the V8. It's something that can't be measured.

But, like I said, I probably wouldn't be 100% sure with either decision. Both are so good, I would just take both: S5 coupe and 335i convertible, perhaps.

Star - 9/5/2007 11:26:23 AM

+1 Boost

From what I see in this video the Audi doesn't offer enough to justify the difference in price in my opinion. But I can accept that somebody might have a different opinion.

iamdabest1 - 9/4/2007 8:29:38 PMView My AgentSpace

+2 Boost

335i being 10,000 dollars less i think is the better choice BUT the S5 is alittle more exclusive and you will see much less of them so therefore will turn more heads.
when a car does 0-60 in 4.5 or 5.0 .5 seconds is sooooo little you guys have no idea it really will come down to the winner being the better driver.

anyone who can afford these 50,000 dollar cars will be happy with either one and still look at eachother with envy when side by side at a red light.

reply to this comment

TauronB2G - 9/4/2007 8:33:00 PM

+1 Boost

great video. I love the 335 engine but I think the audi looks better. I wouldn't buy either though.
T

reply to this comment

enthusiastx11 - 9/4/2007 8:49:00 PM

+3 Boost

just curious...what would you buy in the $45,000 range?

S4cabriofoxone - 9/5/2007 12:04:05 AMView My AgentSpace

+1 Boost

He has a CLK550. So nothing- that car is pushing 70.

enthusiastx11 - 9/4/2007 8:47:38 PM

+2 Boost

another odd comparison...335i inline six should be compared to A5 six. S5 v8 should be compared to M3 v8.

despite that (and a $10,000+ price advantage), the BMW wins.

and did anyone notice the grins on that woman when she was driving the BMW? ; ) not the same in the audi.

reply to this comment

rg12345 - 9/4/2007 11:04:15 PM

+4 Boost

And so, I guess, the 6 cylinders in Porsche should NOT be compared to any V8, eh ? Nice, cause Porsche's little engine can kick some ass in the V8 department. Hahaha

S4cabriofoxone - 9/5/2007 12:05:36 AMView My AgentSpace

0 Boost

Did it ever occur to you, enthusiast, that Audi did not design this car to compete directly with the E92? It is strange how these comparos are aligned, but the A5 is slightly better than the 328xi, the S5 is a little better than the 335xi and the RS5 will be a little better than the M3. They're all in-between. It's interesting, how that works.

enthusiastx11 - 9/5/2007 2:24:53 AM

+2 Boost

i'd never compare the porsche to a 3-series. completely different class of car in terms of size and price.

chewy - 9/4/2007 11:22:26 PMView My AgentSpace

+2 Boost

Nice tie, I bet if she took another lap in either the results would be within a couple of tenths but completely different. All depends on how intensly she took each lap.

reply to this comment

utahnkid - 9/4/2007 11:31:27 PM

0 Boost

I would love to see Audi's V8 push out some more ponies. If I was comparing strictly off of numbers I would way rather take BMW's six with just 45 less hp and all the fuel economy plus weight savings. Now if you were talking more like a 100 hp difference between the two I would LOVE to take the V8... You just can't beat there sound and immediate power delivery. Now this would require they SIGNIFICANTLY increase the current RS4's power output as to not encroach on sales, so is it gonna happen? Probably not. But just imagine that.. An S4 pushing 400 hp with a beefy V8 and Quattro (don't forget the standard amazing Audi interior) for under 50k... Mmmm sign me up

reply to this comment

S4cabriofoxone - 9/5/2007 12:08:33 AMView My AgentSpace

+2 Boost

Yes, they will, bulldogz. It's called supply and demand. Both the RS4 and R8 have been selling out, but they're only slightly increasing demand. They're not going to over-produce; it's profitable and smart. It keeps the car more interesting.

"You just can't beat there sound and immediate power delivery. Now this would require they SIGNIFICANTLY increase the current RS4's power output as to not encroach on sales, so is it gonna happen? Probably not."

Well, the thing is, that IS the RS4/RS5. They're the super-powerful, top-of-the-line ones. They'd have to eliminate the S4/S5 and push the RS4/RS5 slightly downmarket for that, but that would be sad. The S4 has a name, it has a past. I love how they position the S/RS cars-- just out of reach for top-end, non "M" BMWs (S cars), and just a bit better than the "M" models (RS cars), with pricing to match.

utahnkid - 9/5/2007 2:58:44 PM

0 Boost

I know, I know.. The S and RS are arranged pretty well in the market, it's just that I've always seen Audi as the underdog and recently they've really made a comeback so I'm just thinking of ways they could really cut BMW's throat on the 3 series. The 335i is a pretty amazing little car so if Audi could go beyond competing and come out with something that clearly dominates it for around the same price, I can't imagine it would be a bad thing. The S4 definitely holds its own against the 335 but I wanna see it really clear cut, no arguments about it, beat it. How about this for a dream engine line up:

S3=300hp (turbo'd six) S4=400hp (V8) S5=500hp (turbo'd V8) (see the trend?) RS4=470hp (turbo+superchargerd V8) RS5 & RS6=600hp (turbo'd V10) Mmmmmmm

AdmiralT20 - 9/6/2007 11:57:54 AM

+1 Boost

3=300hp (turbo'd six) S4=400hp (V8) S5=500hp (turbo'd V8) (see the trend?) RS4=470hp (turbo+superchargerd V8) RS5 & RS6=600hp (turbo'd V10) Mmmmmmm

S5 is the coupe version of S4, so it won't be necessary to serve them with different engines.
RS5 is the coupe version of RS4.
RS6 is a class up on the RS4/RS5.

esquire - 9/5/2007 3:59:47 AM

+6 Boost

i like both. the 3 is a bit more sportier but the s5 has a richer interior and a more sophisticated exterior.

to date in so cal, ive seen a lot of 3s primarily driven by women or college kids. it almost looks like kids are getting them for graduation presents. lol. i have seen a few that had wheels and looked very nice. the higher cost of the s5 alone will make it more difficult for younger folk to acquire one and thats a pretty good reason in itself for choosing a s5 over a 3.

the cabin and motor in the new a4 are supposedly pushed back to better balance the nose weight bias. it should be a great performer with awd.

reply to this comment

amazinBimmer - 9/5/2007 8:12:50 AM

-7 Boost

to the morons..
a) they are both not good cars... the BMW is. the audi is a POS that shows its flaws openly by getting its ass kicked with awd and a 54hp advantage.

b) the BMW is so much more desirable. end of story.

c) why pay the premium for a 's line car" when you can pay a few more daollars and buy the almighty "M".

reply to this comment

GermanNut - 9/5/2007 9:00:45 AM

+4 Boost

I agree amazinBimmer, or why not pay more for the almighty Audi RS that has already smacked and defeated the new M3 in RS4 sedan form twice.

Just look at those RS6 avant leaked pictures amazinBimmer. 580 horsepower 0-100 km/h .2 seconds faster than the BMW M5 and 0-200 km/h a full second faster than both the M5 and E63 AMG.

If the old Audi RS6 plus managed to pull off 0-100 km/h in 4.6 seconds look for the new avant to go 4 second flat and the sedan....that thing will be in the 3's

reply to this comment

JRobUSC - 9/5/2007 2:47:19 PM

+2 Boost

wow, a full second faster 0-200kph? That'll be totally useful next time I am drag racing an M5 or E63 at a redlight on a city street from a stop to 124mph.

ThierryHenry14 - 9/6/2007 9:54:09 PM

+1 Boost

this usually also means a faster 100-200kph (62-124 mph)...

BimmerFan - 9/5/2007 10:40:31 AM

-1 Boost

There is truth to BMW being THE Ultimate Driving Machine...

...and Vicki is HOT!

reply to this comment

Star - 9/5/2007 11:27:24 AM

+2 Boost

"...and Vicki is HOT!"

Not from where I'm looking..

MrGunFun - 9/5/2007 12:06:18 PMView My AgentSpace

+1 Boost

any women look hot when driving BMW and smile.

reply to this comment

1995e34 - 9/5/2007 4:01:54 PM

+1 Boost

prestige:

1. noun, "reputation or influence arising from success, achievement, rank, or other favorable attributes."

i think some are using this word in reference to the individual driving the car rather than the car itself. that would be a status symbol rather than a prestigeous car. i don't need a car to let the world know i've made it. some guys do.

reply to this comment

indoctrin8ed - 9/5/2007 6:20:41 PM

+3 Boost

Thank you 5th Gear! Your reviews show the real differences between these cars!

reply to this comment

indoctrin8ed - 9/5/2007 6:24:12 PM

+3 Boost

BMW clearly wins this. Anything that the Audi has over the BMW is offset by the 5,000 pounds ($9000 US dollar?) difference. The BMW is lighter, more nimble, more driver feedback, less expensive, and arguably quicker. The BMW also was first to market by almost a year.

And those giggles that Vicki had as she was kicking the rear out on the BMW clearly illustrate which car is MORE FUN TO DRIVE!

And isn't that why enthusiasts buy cars - because they are fun to drive?! Great job, BMW.

reply to this comment

bmw4meonly - 9/6/2007 12:58:07 AM

+4 Boost

I knew before the start of the race the BMW would outperform the Audi.BMW "ALWAYS" out performs cars that have a substansial horsepower rating.They do it by balance and by the knowledge of building great sports cars that "kick ass".Nobody touches BMW!.

reply to this comment

Audiphile - 9/6/2007 2:48:31 PM

0 Boost

We don't know how long the straights were, or how "fast" the curves were, on this racetrack. We also don't know whether these cars were Euro-spec or American-spec. Were the two cars provided by their respective manufacturers, or did one marque provide both cars (like a recent BMW 330i-Infiniti G37 match), with possible conflicts of interest affecting the outcome? Finally, is the S5 a pre-production model or the "final product"? All of these factors could have affected the outcome. I for one will wait until the S5/A5 is available in the U.S. before I pass judgement.

reply to this comment

	omarrana I hooked up my accelerator to my brake lights. I hit the gas, people behind me stop, and I'm gone.
	View My AgentPage