If you tuned in last night you would have seen that our top story featured the likes of the Jeep Grand Cherokee, Mercedes-Benz M-Class, Porsche Cayenne and Volkswagen Touareg all in diesel form competing against each other in a MotorTrend battle.
It was refreshing to see the Jeep Grand Cherokee wind up with the "W."
Well, it turns out another buff book published a diesel head-to-head comparison featuring the same exact vehicles BUT added the BMW X5 diesel. So, how did it pan out?
Not even close to what we saw from MT. This is how the vehicle's were ranked:
1) Volkswagen Touareg
2) Porsche Cayenne
3) Mercedes-Benz M-Class
4) Jeep Grand Cherokee
5) BMW X5
So, how did Car and Driver deduce these results? You'll have to click "Read Article" to find out...
That said, who do YOU think actually got it right? C&D or MT?
Read Article